illinois labor market review

Volume 6, No.4
Winter 2000


ILMR Homepage

Feature Articles:
Portal Page Web site:
Access the Information You Need, All in One Place


Rapid Respone Unit:
What Employers and Dislocated Workers Need to Know

Help for Illinois Employers
The Industrial Training Program (ITP) and the Manufacturing Extension Partnership of Illinois (MEPI)

Union Membership in 2000:
Numbers Decline During Record Economic Expansion

Archives

Union Membership in 2000:
Numbers Decline During Record Economic Expansion

By: Rich Reinhold

Union membership in the U.S. decreased in 2000 even as the national economy continued to grow and the unemployment rate reached 30-year lows. Despite the recent good economic times, the union membership levels were lower in 2000 then they were during the recession of the early 1990s, suggesting that most of the jobs created during the economic expansion were non-union. In the past ten years, the number of employed workers in unions fell by about 482,000, while the percentage of employed workers in unions dropped from 16 percent to 13.5 percent (see table below).


UNION MEMBERSHIP IN THE U.S., ILLINOIS
United States
Illinois
%Private
%Public
Union
%of
Sector
Sector
Union
%of
YEAR
Members*
Employed
Employed
Employed
Members*
Employed
2000
16,258
13.5
9.0
37.5
1,046
18.6
1999
16,477
13.9
9.4
37.3
993
18.0
1998
16,211
13.9
9.5
37.5
1,004
18.9
1997
16,110
14.1
9.8
37.2
971
18.5
1996
16,269
14.5
10.2
37.6
1,043
20.0
1995
16,360
14.9
10.3
37.7
1,042
20.2
1994
16,740
15.5
10.8
38.7
N/A
N/A
1993
16,598
15.7
11.1
37.7
N/A
N/A
1992
16,390
15.7
11.4
36.6
N/A
N/A
1991
16,568
16.0
11.7
36.9
N/A
N/A
1990
16,740
16.0
11.9
36.5
N/A
N/A
1983
17,717
20.1
16.5
36.7
1,064
24.2
*In thousands
Sources: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics and Bureau of National Affairs

Union Membership Falls in Private Sector but Remains High in Government

The industry sector with the highest level and rate of union membership in 2000 was Government (37.5 percent). Within total Government, Local Government had the largest number of union members and the highest rate of unionization, with the bulk employed in local police and fire departments. Government union membership has risen by over 1.3 million or 24 percent since 1983.

The private sector, by comparison, had nine percent of its workers in unions in 2000. The unionization rate in the private sector was relatively stable for the past decade, dropping to 12 percent in 1990, but it is now nearly half the rate of the early 1980s. Nearly one out of four workers in the Transportation-Public Utilities industry was a union member and about 20 percent of all Construction workers were unionized. Manufacturing had about 17 percent of all union members and about one third of all union members in the private sector. But in just the previous four years, union membership in Manufacturing has decreased by over 500,000.

Protective Services Workers Have Highest Percentage of Union Workers

The occupations with the highest percentage of union membership were Protective Services, including local police and fire fighting workers (39 percent) and Transportation and Material Moving occupations (23 percent). Sales and Farming-Forestry-Fishery occupations each had unionization rates of less than five percent. The vast majority of union members were those employed as full-time workers; only seven percent of part-time employees belonged to unions.

Men, especially those ages 45 and older, had the highest rates of union membership. Blacks had a higher rate of union membership (17 percent) as compared to Whites (13 percent) and Hispanics (11 percent). Within race/gender categories, one out of five Black men employed was a member of a union and about 10 percent of Hispanic women were in unions.

Union versus Non-Union Job Earnings Differential Largest for Women, Racial Minorities

Across all industries, the average weekly earnings for union members were 28 percent higher than for those employed in non-union jobs. The gap between union and non-union earnings was largest for Hispanics and Blacks. The earnings for Hispanics in unionized jobs were 55 percent higher than Hispanics in non-union positions. Black workers in unions earned nearly 40 percent more than Blacks in non-union jobs. The earnings for Women in unionized positions were nearly one-third higher than for Women in non-union jobs.

Workers employed in unionized Service and Farming-Forestry-Fishery occupations reported earnings that were 69 percent and 59 percent higher, respectively, than their non-union counterparts. There was virtually no difference in the earnings of union and non-union workers employed in Managerial/Professional Specialty occupations.


2000 Average Weekly Earnings: Union and Non-Union Workers
Union
Non Union
Difference
All Workers
696
542
28%
Men
739
620
19%
Women
616
472
31%
White
716
565
27%
Black
596
436
37%
Hispanic
584
377
55%
Managerial/Prof Specialty
840
836
0%
Technical, Sales, Administrative
598
497
20%
Service Occupations
554
327
69%
Precision Production, Craft, Repair
784
570
38%
Operators, Fabricators & Laborers
605
411
47%
Farming, Forestry, and Fishing
516
325
59%
Mining
746
774
-4%
Construction
814
529
54%
Manufacturing
630
587
7%
Transportation-Public-Utilities
768
639
20%
Wholesale, Retail Trade
518
439
18%
Finance-Insurance-Real Estate
596
621
-4%
Government
730
609
20%
Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics

Those industries with the highest unionization rates, not surprisingly, had the largest ratio of union to non-union earnings. Unionized Construction workers made 54 percent more than non-union Construction workers, while unionized workers in Transportation-Public-Utilities and Government reported earnings levels that were 20 percent higher than non-union workers in the same industries. Within the Mining and Finance-Insurance-Real Estate industries, the earnings for union members were slightly lower than the earnings for non-union members.

Illinois Union Membership Grows Modestly in 2000 but Downward Trend Continues

The percent of people employed in Illinois who belonged to unions grew slightly to 18.6 percent in 2000 but was still lower than just five years earlier when membership was at 20.2 percent (see table). As of 2000, Illinois had the third largest number of union members and the 6th highest unionization rate among all states. However, there has been a downward trend in Illinois union membership since the early 1980s, when nearly one out of four employed workers were in unions. The actual number of union members in Illinois was about the same in 2000 as it was in 1983 but the unionization rate in 2000 was nearly six percent lower than in 1983.

Data included in this article were obtained from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and the Bureau of National Affairs (BNA). The full BLS report on union members in 2000 may be obtained at http://stats.bls.gov/newrels.htm. The BNA Web site address is http://www.bna.com.


Rich Reinhold has worked at IDES since 1992 and currently holds the position of Manager of Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS). His education includes a master’s degree in economic development from the University of Illinois at Chicago. Contact him by
e-mail: rreinho@ides.state.il.us,
phone 312-793-5896 or
fax 312-793-2192.



last updated: May 1, 2001